diff options
| author | Jonas Smedegaard <dr@jones.dk> | 2025-09-03 14:12:07 +0200 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Jonas Smedegaard <dr@jones.dk> | 2025-09-03 14:12:07 +0200 |
| commit | 70d0a51811b5f335e28b9226eefc4d06e3a77b86 (patch) | |
| tree | 01e112f7b1ffb78cce7a035616d22c4b672ecc82 | |
| parent | c6ca6a9b1c0b87b5a0564ea4901b9769025e1934 (diff) | |
draft notes
| -rw-r--r-- | _subsidiarity.qmd | 74 | ||||
| -rw-r--r-- | ref.bib | 85 |
2 files changed, 159 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/_subsidiarity.qmd b/_subsidiarity.qmd new file mode 100644 index 0000000..972c576 --- /dev/null +++ b/_subsidiarity.qmd @@ -0,0 +1,74 @@ +# Baggrundsmateriale om subsidiaritet + +Indenfor statskundskab er subsidiaritetsprincippet +(også kaldet nærhedsprincippet) +en form for decentralisering. +Decentralisering dækker ifølge @Faguet2023 [p. 24] +over flere væsensforskellige ting: +Delegering (spredning af magtapperat ud til lokalområder), +devolution (øget autonomi for lokalområder) +og privatisering (konvertering til konkurrence i lokalområder). +Subsidiaritetsprincippet præciseres +som værende en form for devolution +[@Devarajan2023 p. 77]. + +Cory Doctorow [beskriver] subsidiaritet i en digital kontekst: + +> Subsidiarity keeps data +> "as close as possible to the social context of creation;" +> relies on "a plurality of solutions" +> that are federated and interoperable; +> and it leverages and extends +> "online and offline trust and institutions." + +[beskriver]: https://pluralistic.net/2022/05/12/crypto-means-cryptography/ + +Digital sibsudiaritet beskrives også i en [artikel i Wired] +(udgivet samme dato som Doctorows blogindlæg). + +[artikel i Wired]: https://web.archive.org/web/20250805132902/https://www.wired.com/story/web3-blockchain-decentralization-governance/ + +Både Doctorow og Wired kobler subsidiaritet med en +"plurality of solutions" - +mangfoldige løsninger fremfor monokultur. + +Min akademiske sparringspartner, Bernelle Verster, +ser også subsidiaritet o pluralitet som centrale begreber, +og har bl.e. fundet at politikeren Chantal Mouffe opererer i det felt: +https://indiebio.co.za/chantal-mouffe-and-my-game/ + +## Permakultur + +Akademiske tekster indenfor filosofi om permakultur: + +"Permaculture education as ecology of mind: the head, hands and heart of transformation" +frames permaculture as a philosophy of mind +and transformative praxis, integrating personal, interpersonal, and ecological dimensions +[@Henfrey2017]. + +"Permaculture" +characterizes permaculture as an ethical, pragmatic, philosophical and technical response +to the Anthropocene, emphasizing its "work with nature" ethos +[@Chakroun2023]. + +"Permaculture Principles, Practices, and Environmentalism" +offers a philosophical and ethical analysis of permaculture's core triad: +Earth Care, People Care, Fair Share, +and explores its implications for environmental philosophy. + +"Assessment of permaculture integration into gray and mainstream agriculture" +er en analyse over akademiske udgivelser, +som indikerer at permakultur bliver belyst filosofisk +[@ForteTaylor2025]. + +Ingen af teksterne synes at cementere permakultur som filosofisk +i akademisk forstand. + +En ikke-akademisk tekst som måske uanset kan være en nøgle for os er +<https://www.permaculture.org.uk/articles/basics-permaculture-ethics-and-principles-alex-heffron> +som fremhæver at permakultur kritiseres for at være +"just a set of fanciful theories" - +måske det problem vi undersøger kunne være, +hvorvidt vi kan argumentere for at permakultur er en form for etik +i videnskabelig moralfilosofisk forstand, +eller hvis ikke, så at identificere hvad der er diskvalificerende. @@ -0,0 +1,85 @@ +@InBook{Faguet2023, + author = {Jean-Paul Faguet}, + pages = {21--48}, + title = {Understanding decentralisation: theory, evidence, and practice}, + doi = {10.31389/lsepress.dlg.b}, + crossref = {Faguet2023book}, +} + +@InBook{Devarajan2023, + author = {Shantayanan Devarajan and Stuti Khemani}, + pages = {75--98}, + title = {Realising the promise of partial decentralisation}, + doi = {10.31389/lsepress.dlg.d}, + crossref = {Faguet2023book}, +} + +@InBook{Chakroun2023, + author = {Leila Chakroun}, + pages = {279--283}, + title = {Permaculture}, + crossref = {Wallenhorst2023book}, + doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-25910-4_43}, +} + +@InBook{Henfrey2017, + author = {Tom Henfrey}, + pages = {171--185}, + title = {Permaculture education as ecology of mind}, + comment = {https://www.researchgate.net/publication/319834889_Permaculture_education_as_ecology_of_mind_the_head_hands_and_heart_of_transformation}, + crossref = {Hall2017book}, + doi = {10.5040/9781474267618.ch-013}, + file = {:Henfrey2017 - Permaculture Education As Ecology of Mind.pdf:PDF}, + subtitle = {The head, hands and heart of transformation}, +} + +@Book{Faguet2023book, + editor = {Jean-Paul Faguet and Sarmistha Pal}, + publisher = {LSE Press}, + title = {Decentralised governance}, + isbn = {9781909890855}, + booksubtitle = {Crafting Effective Democracies Around the World}, + booktitle = {Decentralised governance}, + date = {2023-09}, + doi = {10.31389/lsepress.dlg}, + file = {:Faguet2023book - Decentralised Governance.pdf:PDF}, +} + +@Book{Wallenhorst2023book, + editor = {Nathanaël Wallenhorst and Christoph Wulf}, + publisher = {Springer International Publishing}, + title = {Handbook of the {Anthropocene}}, + isbn = {9783031259104}, + booksubtitle = {Humans between Heritage and Future}, + booktitle = {Handbook of the Anthropocene}, + date = {2023}, + doi = {10.1007/978-3-031-25910-4}, + file = {:Wallenhorst2023book - Handbook of the Anthropocene.pdf:PDF}, +} + +@Article{ForteTaylor2025, + author = {Roberto Carlos {Forte Taylor} and Osborne Grant Clark and Julien Jean Malard-Adam}, + title = {Assessment of permaculture integration into gray and mainstream scientific literature in four languages}, + issn = {1773-0155}, + number = {4}, + volume = {45}, + date = {2025-06}, + doi = {10.1007/s13593-025-01017-2}, + file = {:ForteTaylor2025 - Assessment of Permaculture Integration into Gray and Mainstream Scientific Literature in Four Languages. a Review.pdf:PDF}, + journaltitle = {Agronomy for Sustainable Development}, + publisher = {Springer Science and Business Media LLC}, + subtitle = {A review}, +} + +@Book{Hall2017book, + editor = {Richard Hall and Joss Winn}, + publisher = {Bloomsbury Academic}, + title = {Mass Intellectuality and Democratic Leadership in Higher Education}, + isbn = {9781474267618}, + date = {2017}, + doi = {10.5040/9781474267618}, +} + +@Comment{jabref-meta: databaseType:bibtex;} + +@Comment{jabref-meta: fileDirectory-jonas-bastian:/home/jonas/Projects/RUC/LIB/subsidiarity;} |
